Annotation4 ─ Listen children ’s voice!

Annotation4 ─ Listen children ’s voice!

        Many parents will think strict education as the only way to let children get better position in their future. However, some of them can’t even control how strict is useful and efficient. Sometimes, parents think the discipline they give is appropriate, on the other hand, in fact, is a poison to the children.

        Celine Raphael is a talented child who is good at playing the piano. However, everything changes when she is “crowded” by this title. In order to let Celine become a professional pianist, her father starts to force Celine to practice the piano day and night, even stop her from having a normal life that a child deserves. Furthermore, her father even used belt to whip her once she made mistake, or other much more terrible punishments. In the end, Celine finally stood out and fought for her liberty. She successfully made her dream come true, being a doctor instead of a pianist.

         From Celine’s biography, we can find the difference of idea and feelings between parents and children. Although Celine’s father punished Celine strictly and mercilessly, even making Celine have anorexia, he denied every charges from Celine. He imputed his cruel deed to Celine’s bad-behaved. We can find that, something parents think is good for children may, in fact, hurt children most seriously. However, parents will just name this discipline a good way to let their children have a wonderful future. But, do these deeds really come from the truly hope for children? I don’t think so.

        Many parents will force their children to learn the instrument or dance or other accomplishments because they want their children to finish what they couldn’t accomplish. Celine’s father once dreamed to play the piano, however, because his parents couldn’t afford this expenses. Instead of trying to understand what Celine really wanted, he just thought that Celine was good at playing the piano, so she had to develop her talent without other excuses. This projection is the biggest problem the most parents will have.

        Some parents will feel some kind of guilty when they punish their children, then they will try to give their children some consolations. However, even if you pull the nail out of the wall, there’s still a mark on it. Celine’s father will embrace her in the night to get Celine’s forgiveness after he punish her. But he will go on his terrible discipline and humiliation day after day. Father want to make up their relationship by a little hug. But to Celine, her hurt can’t restore so easily.

        Celine has mentioned that her father is growing up under a harsh environment and education from his father. His father also use strict method to educate him. Although Celine’s father really get a good position in the future, his mind also become anomalistic. Is this really what his father want to give him? From her father’s childhood, we can also discover one thing. A strict education may really make your children have a better work or achievement, but their mind may also have so influence by your inappropriate treatment.

        From Celine’s biography, we can understand those who is under the education from the parents like Mother Tiger. When parents just see the good side from Mother Tiger’s book, maybe they should read this book to avoid making the mistake like Celine’s father.

參考資料

Celine Raphael(2013)。過度教育。台北縣：寶瓶文化事業有限公司。